Saturday, October 13, 2007

The Supreme Court has less power?

The Supreme Court is without power or influence in our country, argues one writer in Time magazine. I find this a rather queer assessment of the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS), indeed.

An article from Time decidedly thinks the justices of the Court are in a bit of a funk when it comes to their constitutional authority; I respectfully disagree.

Although, the article defends the record of the Court on many of the hot issues, such as abortion, civil rights, etc., that have come before it in the past fifty years, it points out that many of the life-altering decisions it used to render are far between in frequency.

It is true that the SCOTUS does not affect such issues as abortion on a daily basis, but it did give us a very terrible beginning for a new century, through its appointment of George W. Bush as president.

This single, unconstitutional decision will affect America--and the world--moreso than its decisions on abortion and civil rights, for years to come. It is evident that the Supreme Court acted beyond its scope when it issued an opinion on Bush v. Gore (2001), which ultimately reversed the decision of a state supreme court. When this case was expedited to them, the conservative members of the Court could smell the blood in the water and became as if sharks circling it until they had their fill. Now, the United States must recover from this horrible, make-shift president for many, many years to come.

A truly impartial Court would have refused the case Bush v. Gore (2001). The Florida Supreme Court had already issued its ruling on a rather cut-and-dry states only issue. As a consequence, the SCOTUS should never have issued a writ of certiorari. The Tenth Amendment of the United States Constitution awards protection to individual states' quasi-sovereignty from the overly busy body style of the federal government, which includes the Supreme Court.

It is obvious that Florida's electoral process falls within this selective purview of states' autonomy.

Furthermore, how can anyone argue that a branch of the federal government, which is comprised of nine elite members, who are non-beholden to the people and have lifetime tenure, are without power? The greatest obstacle they must face is receiving confirmation from the United States Senate. Despite public opinion, once that is realized their career path in life is set through retirement (or death).

Seemingly, the justices of the Supreme Court may not hear landmark cases on a daily basis, such as Roe v. Wade (1973) or Bush v. Gore (2001), which seem to retain their longevity long past their surface expiration dates, but they do play a vital--and often times autocratic--function in our democratic model of government.

No comments: