Tuesday, June 19, 2007

Signing Statements: Are they legal or foolish?

Based on the belief that his administration is above the law, President George W. Bush issues decrees called "signing statements."

President Bill Clinton lost the line-item veto, when the Supreme Court found it to violate the "separation of power" clause of the Constitution, even though it was given to him by Congress; however, Bush gave himself signing statements. Congress has been rather mute on the subject, until recently.

Congress sends the president a bill, that he must either sign or veto, at his discretion. This power is within his constitutional purview as the executive officer of the United States. No problem, right? Wrong!

Many times when Bush signs a law he limits it, or so he thinks, by appending little statements to it. For example, he retains the right to "revise, interpret or disregard provisions on national security and constitutional grounds." Let's see who really has the authority to do the things he claims he has the right to do.

Revise.

Seemingly, any bill that Congress passes has been revised, through the legislative process. It goes through committees in both the House of Representatives and the Senate. It's openly debated on the floors of both houses of Congress. Then those two houses must work out compromises so a single piece of legislation is passed, before being sent to the president, who can either accept or reject the bill in its entirety. He cannot simply pick and choose the parts he agrees with and sign them into law, or retain the right to revisit the law at a later date to reject or revise parts of it.

Interpret.

Who gets to interpret the laws of the United States, which are authorized by Congress and signed into law by the president? Let's see, could it be the Supreme Court? Yes, of course!

The Constitution of the United States very clearly defines the Supreme Court as the ultimate interpreter of the laws of the United States. The president cannot, simply by appending it onto a law, retain the right to later interpret or disregard a law, at his discretion.

Disregard.

Now, let's examine who can disregard a law of the United States. Simply, the answer is quite simple: no one can disregard a law of the United States, even the president! Even though, he found the First Amendment and Fourth Amendment sort of pesky when he was doing those illegal wiretaps of American citizens. It's too bad the Republican-led Congress, at the time, was too weak and subservient to hold him accountable for his crimes.

Simply put: the president cannot act as both the legislative and judicial branches of the United States. He must act solely within those powers granted his office by the Constitution. Anything more places the president in violation of federal law and official precedent. The president may not act extra-constitutionally, in other words.

It would finally seem that some members of the Congress are taking the president's little revisions to heart and seeing them as a direct assault on their constitutional powers. Members of the Senate, such as Robert C. Byrd (D-WV), and the Senate Judiciary Committee, chaired by John Conyers (D-MI), have asked the Government Accountability Office (GAO) to provide them with a report that shows how the president has overstepped his authority.

It is my sincere hope that the Congress will vigorously investigate these frauds committed on the American people by the president of the United States.

No comments: